Paying for Edits?


Photo from

To hire an editor or not to hire an editor. To trust my own instincts to catch every dangling modifier and wrong POV… My apologies to Shakespeare. But this is a question that often plagues writers. It’s on the top of a list of things we must decide as we prepare our manuscripts for publication. And it is in my humble opinion the decision that can make or break your career.

Editing isn’t cheap. At least it’s not if you hire someone who really knows what they are doing. An editor can realistically charge $35 to $200 an hour. GULP! If you have never taken the time to edit someone else’s work, you can’t truly appreciate their value.

Why you don’t want to rely on free edits

Think of the hours you’ve spent crafting your book. Hours of self-editing (at least I hope you do.) You hand it off to a writer friend to give it a once over. (Translation: look for blaring errors.) That can take hours of their time. And because they are doing it as a favor to you, they are not going to give you a detailed edit, they don’t have the time. Unless they are OCD about finding every dot and tittle that needs fixing. You will get some good help but errors may still abound.

You get what you pay for. Free can leave you wanting. Besides, your fellow authors may focus on specific things that are always red flags for them. While other obvious things like head hopping may not be a concern. Your friend who is a high school English teacher might find every grammatical error and red mark all your sentence fragments or run-ons. But they may not understand POV or how to write tight for a magazine.

Magazine editors, unless they also write fiction, are not going to be the ideal help for your novel. Actually, it could be more harmful than helpful to solicit free editing from those without the specific editorial skillset needed for your project.

When and how to benefit from free edits

Using free help such as critique groups and fellow authors in the crafting stage is a great way to make you conscious of frequent mistakes you make. But once your baby is done, you need to consider paying an editor.

Find a good fit

Get recommendations from other writers. Ask for a sample edit. You want to see if the editor you’re going to give your hard earned money to gets your voice. Nothing is more disheartening than asking someone to edit your work who changes it so much it no longer sounds like you. I had a friend whose writer friend edited his thesis because he wasn’t really a writer. When he received it back, it sounded like his friend. And the editing changed some points so drastically that the meaning was different. Fortunately, for him this was a free edit. Unfortunately, he was back to square one in the process.

Pay back from a professional edit

My final thought, if you pay an editor before you send your manuscript to a publisher, you’ve got a better chance of getting a contract. A better chance at looking professional in the eyes of the publishing world. You receive a first-hand education into editing by paying close attention to the things the editor has fixed and suggested in your work. It can be a win-win on many levels.

What has your experience been with editors? I love to hear about it.

Over the coming months I’ll be interviewing some editor friends of mine. So….

If you haven’t subscribed to my blog, but you want too…do it now. The subscription button is in the right hand column.


3 thoughts on “Paying for Edits?

  1. Good post, Cindy. I appreciate it.

    A real editor would know the difference between a proofread, as is illustrated in your post picture, and an edit. A content editor would’ve marked “she wondered” in the piece above as being inappropriate for a deep third person POV.

    If your readers are paying for an edit and getting only a proofread, they’re paying too much. Best to learn the different types of edits and know what they want before they seek an editor. That way, they can inform the editor what they want and they can know whether the person they’ve hired knows what he or she is doing.


    • These are great points, Linda. There is so much to learn about the editing process for new writers. It can be daunting. I hope in the months to come I can give some clarity. One thing I find helpful is asking for sample edits. It gives mea feel for how they edit. I almost posted a photo of my manuscript full of red ink but that would have required more work then I cared to deal with at the moment.:) You are right, the photo above doesn’t truly represent the editing we are familiar with on our path to publication. Thanks for sharing.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s